Marshall Silverstein, July 30, 2013

Muhlenberg College: Trexler Library Oral History Repository
Transcript
Toggle Index/Transcript View Switch.
Index
Search this Index
X
00:00:00 - Introduction—Marshall Silverstein's Childhood in Brooklyn, NY

Play segment

Partial Transcript: SC: What is your full name?

MS: The name is Marshall Silverstein. I have a question. You talk about family, and you’re here about business. My family was not in business, but my wife’s family was in business. So we’ll have to differentiate.

SC: We’ll talk about both. But, still, to see the family histories, this is a “life history” type of oral history also.

MS: I was born in Brooklyn on August 18, 1931. Lived in Brooklyn with my parents and my sister and many family members. Whoever didn’t have a home or didn’t know what to do with their lives came to my mother, and she solved all their problems. At one time we had thirteen people living there and one bathroom!

SC: Do you remember the address in Brooklyn?

00:02:36 - Education and Work Experience

Play segment

Partial Transcript: MS: I studied at the Hebrew Institute of Boro Park - which was a Modern Orthodox school. From there I went to Brooklyn Technical High School, which was one of the three most premier schools in the whole five boroughs. Unfortunately, I got sick during the second year and couldn’t travel downtown any longer. So I went to New Utrecht High School. I finished up in the New Utrecht High School in Brooklyn. You want to know about jobs? During the time I went to New Utrecht High School, I delivered orders for the local vegetable man, during the week -- on a bicycle with a basket.

GE: During high school?

MS: Yes, and also worked in New York City, my junior year in high school, delivering laces throughout NYC by hand-truck. At the end of my senior year, I worked at the Pioneer Country Club in the Catskills as a busboy and a waiter.

00:07:41 - North American Aviation Industrial

Play segment

Partial Transcript: MS: After graduating from school, I got a job in Los Angeles with North American Aviation in industrial engineering, which I had studied at Columbia. I was there a year when once again, my ego was pumped up by the leader of the department said he was leaving, and he asked me to come with him. We both went to Atomics International, where we manufactured atomic reactors for school and experimental purposes. An interesting thing was that I had to get a clearance for atomic energy, which is even higher than top secret. They invaded my block in Brooklyn, knocking on every door to find out, “Who was this guy? What has he done?”

00:08:58 - The Pennsburg Handbag Factory

Play segment

Partial Transcript: MS: I was there for about a year, and I got a letter from my father-in-law, who manufactured handbags, saying his brother was retiring, and he would very much like for me to work with him. I had told him years before that I would. But after I was out on my own. I knew that I could make a living for my family without any help from anyone else. I would consider it - if he would. He said if you want to do it, this is the time to do it. I need the help now.

00:10:30 - Transitioning from Manufacturer to Consultant

Play segment

Partial Transcript: MS: When I was 50, my partner and I had a disagreement – we were the best partners there could be, but he wanted to expand, and I just didn’t feel it was worthwhile. We had two factories and six contractors – and enough is enough. So we said, “Let’s ask our kids if they have any interest.” He had four kids, and four kids were interested. I had three kids and no kids were interested. I did the fair thing and said that he should be able to buy it from me, and he did. We closed the deal on a Friday afternoon, and I said, “I’m free now, I could be semi-retired. I could read books now“. At two o’clock on Thursday afternoon, the next week, I was lying on that couch over there – reading my book, and I got a call from First Valley Bank in Bethlehem. “Marshall, since you have nothing to do with your time, would you like to do some consulting for us?” I said, “Jim, I don’t know what you are talking about.” So he said, “Come on over, “ and we talked. They had some small business loans that weren’t performing. All they had were numbers to look at. They wanted to know why they weren’t performing. I agreed with them, and I took my first assignment. From there on, I was a consultant – no more lying on the couch, reading books.

00:13:14 - Handbags & Luggage

Play segment

Partial Transcript: MS: While we were in the manufacturing business, we started an outlet store and then multiplied those outlet stores by thirteen. It was a very successful business.

SC: What was the name of the outlet store and the pocketbook business?

MS: The name of the outlet stores was “Handbags and Luggage.” We had a store here in Allentown. The major store was in Reading in the outlet stores. And, you’re looking at the guy who talked them into opening that big outlet. They had that store there, and I tried to get into that store. It was all their own merchandise, and they wouldn’t let me in. The CEO there was a very nice guy, Manfred O. Lee (nothing to do with the jeans that they produced.) I met him for breakfast once every couple of weeks, they had a cafeteria there. I tried to outline to him why it would be profitable with all the empty buildings that he had there because they sent their work down South to manufacture. He turned me down all the time. I got a call, he said, “Marshall, we will have a handbag store here before Christmas. Do you want to come in?” Sure, and that evolved from a handbag store to-- not mine, the handbag store was mine – to furniture, everything you could think of, tools, whatever . . . very successful.

00:16:28 - Connections with Samsung, Macy's, Gimbels, Korvette, and Marshalls

Play segment

Partial Transcript: MS: The handbag business - we were bought out by Samsung. I had never heard the word before. They called me up; they wanted me to sell the handbags. I said we were manufacturers, not salespeople. I would introduce them to whatever salespeople he wanted. When I first met him, I said, “Hello, Mr. Sung.” He looked at me and said, “My name is not Sung. I represent Samsung.” “Who is Samsung?” We all know who Samsung is today.

GE: Although I didn’t know about that type of product.

MS: They were manufacturing handbags, but were unable to produce – sell them where they wanted. They had heard about my sales ability – not the mom and pop stores, but the shoe chains and major department stores – that’s where they wanted to go.

SC: What major department stores?

MS: Macy’s, Gimbels, Korvette, everyone that you know of, we sold to.

00:18:46 - Silverstein Family History

Play segment

Partial Transcript: MS: My father was born in Austria and came here when he was a kid. My mother was born in NYC. I’ll give you a little background. My grandfather, my father’s father, must have been wealthy in Europe. They sent him to the United States to study, back in the early 1900s. After he finished studying, he went back to Europe. They financed him in a candy store. He ate the store broke! He ate up all the products! They came here – my father was about ten years old, or something like that. My grandfather was in the piece goods business, selling remnants.

GE: Material?

MS: Yes. My father eventually did the same thing. He would go into one factory and see what they had leftover and go to another factory and tell them this is what I got? Do you want it? This is the price. So he’d go from one factory to another. My father’s name was Herman, and my mother’s name was Anna. His parents were Sam and Goldie.

00:26:12 - Bruch Family History

Play segment

Partial Transcript: SC: Can you talk about your wife’s family, her background now, her family – what you know about the family business?

MS: Let’s take her father, his name was William. He had a brother - they both worked in the handbag factory. Nina’s mother – her [last] name was Agaschevitz, shortened to Agus. A whole bunch of extremely intelligent people – book-wise. [Nina’s mother’s family] One of them wasn’t so smart on the streets. One was a doctor in Brooklyn. He was the smartest one of all. He studied the Tanakh and everything, all the books. He was a brilliant man. Another brother was a professor at Yeshiva University.

GE: I’m sorry. These are Nina’s siblings or Nina’s parents’ siblings?

MS: Nina’s mother’s siblings.

00:29:54 - Marshall Silverstein's Wife—Nina (Pauline) Silverstein nee Bruch

Play segment

Partial Transcript: SC: What’s your wife’s full name? What is Nina’s full name?

MS: Her birth name or current?

SC: Birth name.

MS: Nina Silverstein.

GE: Her name now is Silverstein, what was her birth name?

MS: Bruch. But it wasn’t Nina. It was Pauline.

GE: So Nina is a nickname.

MS: Yes, when she was born, one of her uncles – the one afflicted with Agent Orange – started calling her Nina or Ninya. Nina went to Shulamith School in Brooklyn. That’s the same kind of school that I went to, only it was for girls, mine was for boys. Then she went to Ramaz in NYC for High School, and also college was City College of the City of New York, etc, etc.

00:36:36 - Involvement in the Allentown and Jewish Communities

Play segment

Partial Transcript: SC: [Y]ou talked a little bit about the Jewish community and her work in it, a little bit about your work in it, was there anything else that the two of you did within the community of Allentown and in the Jewish community?

MS: Yes, most of our work, but not all of it, was in the Jewish community, as we were a minority, a very low percentage of the population, so any help you could do, you did. I, myself, was involved in many organizations, including B'nai B'rith, the Jewish War Veterans and most of all, the Jewish Day School. In fact, I was President of the Jewish Day School in the late 70’s – I don’t remember the exact year. We were members of Temple Beth El. At Temple Beth El they asked me to be the President of the Cemetery Association, which I did for twenty-five to thirty years. It was a thankless job, everyone said, but for me, it gave me great pleasure because I didn’t have to go to meetings or anything like that. I did the work, raised a lot of money. We had lot sales [burial plots].

00:40:51 - Development of the Lehigh Valley

Play segment

Partial Transcript: SC: [H]ow do you think the Lehigh Valley has changed in these years?

MS: When I came to Allentown, it was a sleepy little town. You could virtually cross Tilghman Street with your eyes closed. There were no cars coming from either way. Today, it ain’t so baby! At one time, I would say that I knew every Jewish person in town. We were members of three Synagogues. Ultimately, we broke it down to one. It was a wonderful, wonderful community. Everybody was for each other. Now I don’t know, maybe it’s because of our age. I know very few people as compared to that time. But Nina and I were involved in all the Crosses: the Blue Cross, the Green Cross, the Red Cross, whatever.

00:42:58 - Affiliations with Community Synagogues

Play segment

Partial Transcript: SC: What were the names of the Synagogues that you belonged to? Which Synagogue did you join?

MS: The main one was Temple Beth El, also Sons of Israel and Knesseth Israel (KI as it’s currently known.) We were very much involved with the Jewish community. We had a daughter, and when she graduated from college, she toured Europe and went to Israel and liked it there and settled there. We have been to Israel numerous times before. Between my daughter and whatever we were, we have been to Israel about thirty times.

00:43:48 - Diminishing Opportunities in Allentown, PA

Play segment

Partial Transcript: SC: Do you think there is a reason that the next generation isn’t staying in Allentown? At least that's what we've been hearing over and over again, that people have moved away, your children’s generation.

MS: Let’s take a look, what was the leading industry? When we moved here, one of the leading industries - I’m not talking about Air Products, Bethlehem Steel, or whatever. The industries that I knew were the garment trade industry. All those people that you talked about at the meeting at the JCC I know or knew all of them intimately…it’s not so anymore. When the kids grew up, like my kids, this one is a mathematician, this one is a business person. I guess they don’t have the opportunity in Allentown like they have in Washington, DC – where one of them is.

00:45:11 - Marshall Silverstein's Children

Play segment

Partial Transcript: SC: What is that child’s name in Washington?

MS: Elissa Drucker. Another one in Palo Alto, California, in the midst of – what do you call that industry?

GE: High Tech?

MS: High Tech Industry. You walk down the street, and there is the head of Microsoft - shopping in the same store and drugstores. You don’t have that anymore. The last one of them was Bell Labs, part of Western Electric. It’s a different kind of town.

SC: Is that a son or daughter in California?

MS: That’s a daughter.

SC: What’s her name?

MS: Lori Blum. And then I have a son, Ronald, who is with Amtrak for about twenty-five years.

00:49:45 - Origins of the Family Business

Play segment

Partial Transcript: MS: My father-in-law, I can’t tell you why he started the business, but I can imagine. These garment trades – it didn’t take too much money. You bought a couple of sewing machines and put them in the basement and got your wife to sew. He was manufacturing in Connecticut. He had a problem with the Union there. He had a contractor who was making handbags for him in Pennsburg. He was manufacturing in Connecticut, and he might have had one of two other contractors. The plant in Pennsburg – the company- went bankrupt. He got permission from the Referee in Bankruptcy to go into the [Pennsburg] factory and finish off all the bags that they had there.

GE: So they were in Chapter 11?

MS: Yeah the ones in Pennsburg….no maybe Chapter 7 or 13 -Going out of business. He went in there and finished off the bags, and he liked the setup – the life in Pennsburg very much. Between that and the Union in Connecticut, he decided to close in Connecticut and made a deal with the Referee in Bankruptcy and bought all the machines and equipment in Pennsburg, and rented the building in Pennsburg, where he manufactured handbags.

00:56:03 - Charisma la Sac

Play segment

Partial Transcript: GE: So you made pocketbooks. Were they under store labels?

MS: It was under the name we named them, which was “Charisma la Sac.”

GE: Is that two words?

MS: Three words.

GE: Charisma la Sac. When I see the name today, I see the name La Sac.

MS: In that industry, everybody copied from everybody else. It wasn’t patented or copyrighted.

GE: So it was under your own brand name, not a store brand.

MS: No, No, No.

GE: You made pocketbooks. Were there other related products that you made?

00:57:34 - Employees

Play segment

Partial Transcript: MS: We had a line of bags and umbrellas where we personalized it with your name.

GE: Was it personalized by an embroiderer? Or some sort of marker?

MS: Yes. A girl with beautiful handwriting.

GE: Like a calligrapher. You were a manufacturer, so did you have your own sales force?

MS: Absolutely! When you say a sales force, we had a couple salesmen on our payroll, but most of the salespeople were on commission.

GE: They were reps, sales reps?

MS: Yes, all over the country.

GE: And they represented your merchandise as well as others.

MS: Correct.

GE: How large were you? How many people worked there?

MS: In the factory in Red Hill?

GE: About?

MS: I’m just trying to picture it….70. For a while, we had another factory in Wilkes-Barre. But we really depended on contractors to fill what we couldn’t produce.

01:02:14 - Make Well Leather Goods Company

Play segment

Partial Transcript: GE: So, therefore, what you're telling me is that you didn’t just do fashion bags. You also did bags that would be used by companies? Businesses.

MS: No, they were fashion bags. They chose them out of a line. For instance, Mack Trucks, we didn’t make anything special for them other than fasten the bulldog on. They had to let us know beforehand because when we manufactured it, you didn’t want to put it through the lining on the inside, so we would put it through and then fill in the lining. So, it was just for them.

GE: But they were fashion bags? The materials that you were using, was it leather?

MS: Initially, we used the highest grade of vinyl, but expanded vinyl. I would defy anyone – without smelling – to tell if it’s leather or vinyl. The only way they can tell is if there happens to have a scratch on it then, it’s an animal.

01:05:14 - Silverstein's Partner—Izzy Bruch

Play segment

Partial Transcript: GE: So Marshall, you’re saying that the part of the business that you oversaw more was the financial and also the sales side. How about your brother-in-law?

MS: My brother-in-law took care of the manufacturing, and also he designed some bags, and he cut samples to make the bags. We had a high-class designer in New York, called Magda McKay. We had a line of Magda McKay bags.

SC: Is that Magda McKay?

MS: The name just came out. Do you know what they asked me, “What address was I born at.” And you know, I named it just like that.

GE: When your brother-in-law bought you out, did they stay in business for a long time?

MS: Not very long. They went bankrupt.

01:07:30 - Transitioning from Manufacturing to Sales/The End of the Business

Play segment

Partial Transcript: GE: When did you stop manufacturing, and why did you stop manufacturing?

MS: About thirty-five years ago – 1975/1980 – somewhere in that vicinity is when we stopped manufacturing. We were of the belief – we wanted to be “made in USA.” We went to that for years and found competition very, very strong because they [overseas] had it made for half price. Then one year JCPenney – these kinds of stores order six months in advance – not like Macy’s who wants it next week. JCPenney would ordinarily buy from me two, maximum three styles, because they couldn’t put all their eggs in one basket because they bought from many people. So if somebody failed to deliver, they are not out of business. This particular year, JCPenney walked in and loved everything we had and bought thirteen styles. Thirteen styles to us was overwhelming if we are going to continue to produce for Macy’s and Gimbels – so we had to go overseas. We went overseas, and we had these thirteen bags made by a factory, and the next year is when Samsung came to us. Why? Because they have company spies. They knew every style we made there, how many of each color, and they felt if I could sell ours then I could sell theirs.

01:14:48 - Handbags & Luggage (cont'd)

Play segment

Partial Transcript: GE: Tell us a little bit about the Outlet Stores? When did you start that? I know you said that actually became the largest part.

MS: Yes, and by the way, in the contract that I had with Samsung, it said that I would devote my prime hours to Samsung, and I’m the one who decides what the prime hours are. I devote my attention to it, but I could run this outlet store business. And the contract was drawn up legally, so the verbiage was good. Now, what was your question?

GE: With the outlet stores, I was wondering when that started, what did that trajectory look like?

MS: I would say it started about 1965/1970.

GE: Did there seem to be any conflict? In other words, did the other stores have a problem?

MS: No. I didn’t sell my merchandise or very little of my merchandise. I went into New York and just like Marshall’s did – buying excess inventory. I bought their inventory.

01:20:04 - End of the VF Anchor Store

Play segment

Partial Transcript: MS: I will tell you the story of the demise of our business. My partner wanted to expand and expand. I told him we don't have the wherewithal to do it and it's a wrong move. I told him that I would sell off the twelve stores other than VF and work VF, what do they call it today, 24-7. And, well that didn't happen, and so when I left, he started paying attention to new stores to open and he forgot about and didn't pay much attention to VF. And like I said before, VF was the bread and butter and the other ones were little cookies. VF was very proud of what they had. I remember walking in there with Nina about five months later, and I stood in the middle of the store, and I cried. And Nina said what's wrong. I said they are going to kick him out of here any day, and that's what happened. And that's what really triggered the demise of losing that anchor store.

01:22:08 - Impact of the Disappearance of the Textile Industry on the Lehigh Valley's Communities

Play segment

Partial Transcript: GE: Yeah, how do you think the broader community, not just the Lehigh Valley, has been affected by, but even maybe the broader area has been affected by the disappearance of this industry?

MS: I think it's been affected tremendously and when I say tremendously, I am thinking tremendously. There are no more businesses like we knew back then. Mom and pop factories. There were dozens of contractors around here. They weren't handbag contractors around here, but there were blouse contractors and blouse manufacturers and bathing suit manufacturers. There was a company called Neat-Knits who manufactured women's blouses. I forget the name of the other one, the bathing suits, and Mark Stutz's father was in that business and It's a whole different atmosphere now. There we counted on our fingers, we wrote numbers on a piece of paper and we added them up. Now, if you don't have an iPad and a computer, you can't do anything.

01:26:21 - Jewish Involvement in the Textile & Needle-Trade Industries

Play segment

Partial Transcript: GE: Why do you think the Jews tended to be overrepresented in this industry? Why do you think they were maybe overrepresented in this industry as opposed to any other industry? What do you think?

MS: I mentioned something before, and I'll say it again. To get into the garment trade you didn't have to have a lot of money comparatively to start a business. You couldn't start a steel mill if you didn't have money and you couldn't start a department store like Hudson's, if you didn't have money. But you could buy a table, and a pair of shears, and six sewing machines, and some thread and sew up. . . sew up blouses, sew up pocketbooks, sew up anything. And Jews tend to be entrepreneurs, and not many of them had money when they came out from the other country or whatever. And this gave them an opportunity to start their own business.

01:27:48 - Silverstein's Values and Creative Inspirations

Play segment

Partial Transcript: SC: I have a couple other questions, and one of them is, what has your family valued in life most and what do you value in life most?

MS: In one word it is FAMILY. I came from Los Angeles because I told you about my father-in-law asking me, but also our first child was born, and I felt children deserve grandparents and grandparents deserve grandchildren. And to this day, my family is everything. Oh, certainly, friends are very important, but family is primary.

SC: And what has made you feel the most creative, artistic in a metaphoric sense, but creative in life?

MS: Slightly focused, not slightly . . . I'm very focused on numbers. I can manipulate numbers. For my benefit, meaning, for instance, having thirteen stores. These thirteen stores, when you go in stores, people used to pay cash. Yeah, some credit card, some check, most paid cash. Now, there's a store in Texas, there's a store in Florida. You're not there, and I could tell you, I believe, every dollar that hit a cash register went into our till.